
During the winter months, when the cold is at its peak and the chill winds howl outside, there’s nothing quite like the comforting embrace of a hot toddy. This traditional cocktail, made with a delightful mixture of whiskey, hot water, lemon, and honey, is a true winter staple.
The warmth it brings to every sip makes it the perfect companion for those cozy nights by the fireside, where friends gather and laughter fills the air.
A Winter Tradition at the American Club

Located at the heart of Eastern Wisconsin, The American Club is renowned for its luxurious amenities and world-class golf courses, including the spectacular Whistling Straits. In winter, hot toddies are in high demand among the guests. It’s an irresistible choice that adds an extra layer of warmth and comfort to their stay.
Unleashing the Flavors
At The American Club, mixologist Peter Kalleward takes the art of crafting hot toddies to new heights. With a playful laugh, he explains the versatility of this classic cocktail. “We drink hot toddies to stay warm,” he says, “but it’s a drink that can be tailored to suit each guest’s preferences.”
A World of Possibilities
The beauty of hot toddies lies in their ability to combine different spirits and flavors. Whether it’s a smooth Scotch, a rich and velvety rum, or a sophisticated brandy, there’s no limit to what can be used.
However, Kalleward advises selecting a spirit with depth of flavor to truly enhance the experience.
The Age of Discovery
When it comes to choosing a whiskey for your hot toddy, Kalleward recommends opting for aged Bourbons like Buffalo Trace or Russell’s Reserve 10-year. These aged beauties not only impart a richness of flavor but also introduce notes of vanilla, caramel, chocolate, and orange peel. Their mature profiles add a depth and complexity that younger whiskeys simply cannot match.
A Sensory Symphony

If you want to fully appreciate the experience, Kalleward suggests serving your hot toddy in a glass mug. The transparency of the glass allows you to admire the alluring mixture of colors as the warm liquid swirls inside. To complement the drink’s flavors, he recommends indulging in a snack that enhances the overall sensory experience, such as candied hazelnuts or aged cheese.
Your Way, Your Enjoyment
In the end, Kalleward emphasizes that the best way to enjoy a hot toddy is your way. Whether you prefer it neat, with a lemon twist garnish, or even with a touch of cinnamon, the choice is yours. What matters most is the pure enjoyment you derive from each sip.
Frequently Asked Questions
What Is a Hot Toddy?
A hot toddy is a traditional cocktail made with whiskey, hot water, lemon, and honey. It’s a warm and delightful drink that provides comfort during the winter months.
What Are Some Popular Spirits Used in Hot Toddies?
Hot toddies can be made with a variety of spirits, including Scotch, rum, and brandy. Each spirit brings its own unique flavors to the cocktail.
What Are Some Recommended Bourbons for Hot Toddies?
For a truly flavorful hot toddy, aged Bourbons like Buffalo Trace or Russell’s Reserve 10-year are highly recommended. These Bourbons offer a depth of flavor and richness that enhances the overall drinking experience.
How Should a Hot Toddy Be Served?
It’s best to serve a hot toddy in a glass mug. The transparent mug allows you to fully appreciate the colors and appearance of the drink. Additionally, pairing the hot toddy with snacks like candied hazelnuts or aged cheese can further enhance the flavors.
A Final Notes on the Hot Toddy
With its alluring mixture and the warmth it brings, a hot toddy is more than just a cocktail. It’s a reminder of the joys of winter, the pleasure of socializing with friends, and the inner warmth we seek during this festive season.

Leave a Reply